10 Comments
User's avatar
Griffin Gooch's avatar

This is incredible

Expand full comment
Carolyn Morris-Collier's avatar

Well, thank you! It is incredibly long 😂

Expand full comment
Barsley's avatar

"especially because I believe that Christians and Muslims share a noteworthy amount of overlapping ethical commitments in the public square"

I'm not sure, I think there are some issues such as their penchant for mass rape that seem difficult to square with the Christian ethos

Expand full comment
Chris Yokel's avatar

Thank you for cohesively presenting something I've been thinking about in fits and starts for awhile.

Expand full comment
Travis Barrett's avatar

"Besides building the courage of Christians and reminding them of their most lasting legacy and unique calling, namely, to radically love and care for the world around them, I worry [Dominion] has instead been taken as an ego boost." Very well said.

Christians have felt mocked and disrespected for a while, to the point that we might be overeager to uncritically platform voices that actually see faith as valuable in society. Thank you for this post!

Expand full comment
Robert C Culwell's avatar

Love the longboats 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

Maybe someday…..

Expand full comment
Miranda R Waterton's avatar

A really clear and helpful summary of a complex issue. I feel conflicted by Kingsnorth and Martin Shaw: I find many of their ideas on myth, modernity and civilisation very compelling and their faith sincere, but there is a very masculine vibe about this big-bearded, eco-warrior take on the Gospel. My Spider-senses are whispering "patriarchy". It's helpful to have your thoughtful take on this and other currents in modern Christian thought.

Expand full comment
Andrew S Green's avatar

To be fair to Paul Kingsnorth, the “eco warrior” phase is in his past, not his present.

Expand full comment
Gregory Taylor's avatar

Very interesting, but you only need to look at how Christians fare in Muslim countries ( or even in western countries) to see that your take on Islam is rose-tinted.

Expand full comment
JUDGE(not)'s avatar

This sounds interesting; I will give it a read later.

Expand full comment